Tonal Parsimony in Chord-Sequence Analysis: Combining Modulation Cost and Tonal Vocabulary

By François Pachet

François Pachet. “Tonal Parsimony in Chord-Sequence Analysis: Combining Modulation Cost and Tonal Vocabulary.” arXiv:2606.03459, 2026.

About the paper

A chord can fit more than one key. When analyzing a progression, several readings can therefore agree on the fewest key changes and still disagree on how many distinct keys the music uses. Tonal parsimony chooses the reading that uses the fewest distinct keys among those with the minimum number of key changes.

Abstract in brief

The paper compares three ways to assign local keys to chords. It gives exact algorithms for tonal parsimony over the 24 major and minor keys and tests the use of jazz chord substitutions in the analysis. In a collection of 31,032 chord sequences, tonal parsimony used fewer keys than the method based on key changes alone in 55.8% of cases, while preserving the minimum number of key changes.

Related research

Is Solar a Blues? (2000) examines how an earlier MusES system assigned harmonic functions to jazz chord sequences. PDF

The harmonic analysis was implemented in MusES. The project page explains the musical object model and links to the earlier work on jazz chord-sequence analysis.

Predicting the Composer and Style of Jazz Chord Progressions · PDF (2014) studies a related question: how much a jazz chord progression reveals about its composer and style.

The paper also analyzes chord continuations produced with the method from Exact Regular-Constrained Sampling for Variable-Order Markov Generation. See the Markov Constraints project for the code and playground for that generation method.